Ok, so I'm probably on thin ice here. But I can't stop thinking about God and the lottery...
Let me explain.
Following
Muamba's collapse on the football pitch yesterday, the hashtag #prayformuamba became almost instantly trendy. Today, Gary Cahill scored for Chelsea and revealed a shirt saying 'pray for Muamba'. Suarez dedicated his goal in Liverpool's quarter-final victory (just thought I'd slip that in...) to Muamba.
This general consensus that we should be praying for Muamba led to a backlash against prayer, at least on Twitter, and possibly elsewhere.
For my part, I responded to a tweet that a follower had retweeted, saying "No, there is no power in prayer. It doesn't work."
My response was simply to say, "Yes it does, I've tried it loads :)"
The 'conversation' continued:
Him: "Prayer works. One example would be nice." (For 'prayer works', read, 'prayer works, yeah right...')
Me: "I imagine I'd find it almost as hard to 'prove' as you would find it to disprove. My examples wd probably be 'coincidences'."
Him: "No, I can prove it doesn't work quite easily. But the burden of proof is upon the person saying prayer is efficacious."
Me: "Intrigued to know how you can disprove it... Do you mean prove that people don't get what they've asked for?"
At that point, it stopped. Now, I should point out that, given I was shattered and went to bed, there was a time delay of about 20 hours between his last tweet and mine. I'm not, therefore, pretending that my last tweet dealt the killer blow to his argument (!) because he's probably just not noticed that I responded (or can't be bothered to carry on the conversation, which likewise doesn't equal defeat)
But it does rather leave the conversation hanging... Having trawled through some of his tweets, he seems like a well-read kinda guy, and he's not just spouting arguments and then running away. But I'm genuinely wondering what was going to come next. My best guess (as I said in my tweet) is that he would point to 'unanswered' prayer as proof that prayer doesn't work.
Which brings me onto the lottery.
Some UK punter won £38 million on the lottery this weekend.
It wasn't me.
Does that mean I don't believe the lottery exists? Or does the lottery just not work? No, of course neither of them are true. It simply means I've never won it. Buying a lottery ticket, and not winning, doesn't mean the lottery doesn't work, anymore than praying and not getting the answer you want means that prayer doesn't work. If that WAS how prayer worked, everyone would be praying! Clearly prayer can't work like that (although it would be amusing when all however-million praying people won the lottery, and had to share the top prize...)
What amazes me is that prayer so often does work. And I'm not talking about the 'please Lord, help me to have a lovely day', and then rejoicing at bedtime that the day was wonderful and God answered prayer. (Though, I have to say, I do rejoice and am grateful to God for good days, though that's another story...) I mean prayers that seem to go against what one would expect to happen. I know some people would put these all down to coincidences, but I can't accept such a generalisation. Someone told me once about a poster they'd seen saying, 'when I stop praying, coincidences stop happening'.
I guess I'd also refer to my relationship with my parents. And, indeed, with my son.
Asking a parent for something, and getting a 'no' or 'not yet' in response very rarely stops us from asking. With Big Boy, even a 'don't ask again' doesn't stop him from asking... But if I get a 'no' from my parents, does that mean they don't do anything for me, or that our relationship doesn't work? Or does it just mean that, (assuming they're right on this occasion) there's still some stuff in life that I need to learn...?
Isn't it the same with prayer? An 'unanswered' prayer (by which we normally mean we don't get what we wanted) doesn't mean that prayer doesn't work.
It depends on your point of view, of course. Like anything to do with faith, where you start out will affect what you conclude. It's easy for me to believe in the virgin birth, because I believe in a God who created the entire universe. For someone who believes that God doesn't exist, a virgin birth is outside the realms of possibility. Likewise, for me, so called 'unanswered prayer' doesn't tell me that prayer doesn't work. It tells me something else.
As a Christian, I can see the value of prayer. It's not a slot machine - put in request, get what you ask for. It's part of a relationship.
I believe that I have a relationship with God. It would be a bit silly NOT to pray!
I believe that he loves me (and everyone else!) and has the power to do anything. It would be silly NOT to pray.
I believe that he loves to listen to me in much the same way as I love to listen to my kids (except he doesn't have 'off days' where he's super-grumpy). It would be silly NOT to pray.
-------------------------------------------------------
(Just to declare, as I was writing this, the tweeter in question responded, but I decided to go ahead and finish this (I'm rubbish at concentrating on one thing at a time...) and then allow comments to update it
-------------------------------------------------------
Dear fellow tweeter, if my guess is wrong, I apologise :) I would welcome your comments if you fancy writing them here, but would appreciate it, given my intended audience, if you weren't ... uh ... crude. I'm not saying I don't want you to disagree, in fact, I sort of expect you would. But I don't want people to be offended by how anything's said. Thanks!